Never Cry Werewolf

Never Cry Werewolf is a 2008 Canadian horror film about a teenager (Nina Dobrev) who discovers that her new next-door neighbor is a werewolf. The film costarred Peter Stebbings and Kevin Sorbo.

Plot Summary
Jared (Stebbings) buys the house next to Loren (Dobrev) and he family and moves in. Everyone seems to like him, but Loren notices both the creepy vibe he gives off and the creepy interest he seems to have in her. She starts to spy on him; one night, she sees him with a prostitute and then later hears the woman's screams. Loren turns to the Internet and decides that Jared is a werewolf, but no one believes her, even as more bodies pile up. Loren finally enlists the help of Stephen (Sean O'Neill), who has a crush on her, and Redd Tucker (Sorbo), a down-on-his luck reality TV star and big-game hunter. Together they manage to kill Jared's vicious, supernatural dog.

Jared attacks Stephen and infects him with the lycanthropy curse; he will turn into a werewolf unless Loren and Redd can kill Jared, but Redd chickens out and leaves Loren to fight Jared alone. When she tries to, Jared uses his powers to hypnotize her, telling her that she is the reincarnation of his long-lost love and that he plans to turn her into a werewolf as well.

Half-werewolf Stephen and a reluctant Redd arrive to help Loren, and she is able to fight the hypnosis for long enough to shoot Jared with a crossbow. Stephen runs Jared down with a van and Loren is finally able to kill Jared with a shotgun.